When it came to film criticism, my parents were opposites. Dad wasn't too discriminating, he enjoyed Temple of Doom as much as Raiders, and responded to the cheesy 80's Cannon Death Wish sequels as if they had the dramatic intensity of a David Fincher thriller. Mom, however, was usually in the camp of "How could this have been better?"
I'm reminded now specifically of this dichotomy in approaching Godzilla Minus Zero. I loved it -- but it could've been way better. The critical consensus is that it is a thrilling, intense, and loud experience (especially in IMAX), but falls short of its predecessor for its pacing, lack of cohesion, and lapses into melodrama. The "lack of cohesion" is my biggest issue, to which I'd add serious logic problems.
To be clear, I share the opinion that these two films are wonderful and stand a cut above anything else in the series (including Shin Godzilla, which I appreciate for its merits but can't embrace). As Rob Burnett remarked on John Campea's podcast, both Minus movies are way better than we have the right to expect, akin to the Andor of the series. Godzilla Minus Zero had me riveted to my seat for its entirety; it's a buzz-worthy financial and critical success, it once again reminds us that Hollywood can't do Godzilla nearly as well as Japan, and even the popcorn buckets are enthralling -- a new reason to proclaim "Godzilla fans rejoice!"
There is fan service galore here: Fidelity to Ghidorah's "meteoric" origins, and its first attack on Matsumoto City; its designation from Ghidorah to "King" Ghidorah; the titular "Minus Zero" evoking Ghidorah's "Monster Zero" alias; Godzilla's Destroy All Monsters style return to the waters surrounding Manhattan and its swipe at Lady Liberty; the series trope of a PTSD-afflicted old professor out for revenge; and so on. Akira Ifukube's musical fanfares return to herald Godzilla's appearances, though the score, by Naoki Sato, leans into Hans Zimmer, often employing an alarming, sustained siren-like note that sounds like the opening to "Ride of the Valkyries" (I love the smell of fried kaiju in the morning!).
As much as I enjoyed Godzilla Minus Zero, and want to love it wholeheartedly, my out-of-theater reaction was "Yes, but huh?..." And the huh's started nagging me in the movie's first hour.
Minus One introduced Godzilla to a devastated postwar environment whose protagonists had to band together for the survival of their society, earning failed kamikaze pilot Shikishima his redemption and a new family. It was stripped down, and that worked because the landscape was stripped down.
Minus Zero takes place three years later, and the Allied Reconstruction looms large in the subtext. There are a handful of American troops on the ground (reviewers who are blasting the gaijin acting apparently haven't seen Shin, or for that matter any of the previous entries, as these actors aren't nearly as atrocious). The presence of the US Military is appropriately uneasy, and while the Allied involvement -- or lack thereof -- would appear to impact the new issues our protagonists face, more questions are raised than answered. Japan has not only suffered nuclear devastation, but a giant kaiju, and now a second, more threatening one. Despite the societal unease the Japanese people may have experienced during this period (and it's certainly woven into the story), it's no longer realistic that the threat would've been left to about three dozen battle-weary Japanese characters to confront in relative isolation.
Since the original 1954 film, the series often featured scenes of Japanese politicians engaging in heated debates in the Diet parliament building (that is, when Kong wasn't trampling it or Mothra wasn't busy cocooning herself upon it). That Minus Zero foregoes this trope is a missed opportunity; it would've been an economical way to magnify the scale of the threat and the surrounding political complexity. Shin Godzilla focused on that complexity, and if Minus Zero had been expanded even a small percentage in that direction, I think it would've gone a long way in satisfying the big picture.
I also miss the reliable montage of toy tanks, jets and helicopters Tomoyuki Tanaka used to employ to give some idea of the national military scale involved in battling these kaiju. I would've gladly traded a scene like that for the spectacle of King Ghidorah's anti-gravity beam sequence, which was fairly cool but bound to conjure thoughts of Auntie Em's house in the twister. I was also disappointed for a moment when it was reported that Osaka was under attack -- it would've been awesome to actually witness that, but it was just a mention. The overall treatment is subtle enough to feel intimate, but in this case, that works against the scale of the circumstances.
There is enough to go on, by the film's end, to explain why Professor Murakami decides to destroy his research to keep it from the hands of the US military. (I'm not sure it's the best idea to set fire to his lab, in a wooden house, which is surrounded by a neighborhood of wooden houses, but okay.) But I needed a better understanding of why Shikisima and his wife Noriko decided to go on the lam, David Banner style. Little Akiko bawls her eyes out, and it would indeed be heartbreaking if I understood what exactly was going on by this point. Apparently because Noriko's exposure to Godzilla in the Ginza attack three years earlier has afflicted her with some of Godzilla's cellular structure and regenerative traits, which would make her vulnerable to US military study and/or weaponization.
Well, about that: We are told that all others who suffered this affliction are now dead, all cremated. While it's true that Noriko was directly in the path of Godzilla's atomic breath, I found myself questioning how it ended up being just her to have come out of this, considering the multitudes lying around in that hospital flashback. (Hey, is Noriko immortal now? Did she get the Green Mile Mr. Jingles treatment? And what of the metamorphosis, that growth on her back, it's body horror territory but the potential may never be realized. Fanfiction idea: In another three years, Noriko has grown into a full-sized kaiju and uses her connection to Godzilla to tag team against a new threat -- maybe an upscaled Mecha King Ghidorah?!)
So now we have a character with a genetic relationship to Godzilla, and a new character, Aoyama, who appears in one scene to have an almost psychic connection to weather patterns. Don't get me wrong, I love female side characters with psychic connections, but isn't this stacking the deck a little?
Speaking of Aoyama, she is left in charge when Disaster Response leader Noda dies heroically (in the predictable "I'll sacrifice myself to fix a last-minute trivial hardware problem" trope, as there are no other capable troops to take on the task, because there are only seven or eight people left in the entire country to handle all this, oh and they've decided the most secure place to set up HQ is on the roof of the highest standing ruin in Ginza). Upon the defeat of King Ghidorah, Aoyama's first executive action is to order a halt to the naval assault on Godzilla. Surely the outcome will be fine, we have an understanding now, Godzilla appreciates the gesture and will swim away peacefully into Tokyo Bay.
Excuse me, what? Don't get me wrong, after Godzilla blew away Ghidorah I was genuinely heartbroken to see those cannons turn on Big G. More emotionally invested than any scene in the franchise, and that includes Destoroyah. But how is this her decision, unilaterally, to make? All Godzilla has to do is make a half turn, its tail will take out an orphanage, and Aoyama has toddler blood on her hands. The plan was always to try to take a weakened Godzilla out once King Ghidorah was defeated. Sound plan.
Speaking of which, when and how exactly was Ghidorah defeated? Did I blink and miss the shot where Godzilla's death ray not only incapacitates, but disintegrates Ghidorah? Since Ghidorah could suddenly reconnect its severed head and it appeared at the last minute to have taken on Godzilla's regenerative capability, didn't this make it even more of a threat, and elevate the battle stakes?
I'm seeing some online chatter suggesting Ghidora was spared for a possible sequel, but Wikipedia says Ghidorah was in fact defeated by Godzilla's death ray. As this is indeed the probable case, it should've been far more decisive and triumphant.
My takeaway in a nutshell is that a big part of what made Minus One work was the intimate, character-driven scale. By repeating that approach, writer/director/FX director Takashi Yamazaki has succeeded in our continued investment of the characters, but at the expense of doing justice to its own scale. The character bubble worked beautifully in Minus One but works against the broader thematic landscape of the sequel.
All that said, so many recent moviegoing reflections have left me not only disappointed, but outraged (I'm looking at you, Longlegs and Weapons). I don't feel that way here. For me, being a lifelong Godzilla fan means embracing the absurd, the mediocre, the half-baked, in one massive kaiju-sized ball of fun that just keeps growing. Contemplating my issues with Minus Zero has put me in a cozy deep nerd state where forgiveness is already a given, and makes me appreciate the accomplishments of Minus One even more.
So for the moment, I'm grateful to my mom's influence of being constructively critical, and relieved to still have my dad's capacity to suspend cynicism in the name of enjoying simple entertainment on its own terms.
Godzilla fans, rejoice!!